Best 20 Hotels in Shelter Island (NY) to Stay in 2024

Shelter Island (NY) Hotels (city in United States)

1. The Pridwin Hotel

1.4 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.4 /10 (2 reviews)

Experience a tranquil escape like no other at The Pridwin Hotel, located in the charming city of Shelter Island, New York. This 3-star resort villa offers unparalleled views of the surrounding area and provides a serene atmosphere for guests to relax and unwind. With 2 reviews averaging 9.4, this hidden gem is the perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful retreat. Nestled on 81 SHORE ROAD, The Pridwin Hotel boasts a unique charm that sets it apart from other accommodations in the area. Each room is designed with comfort in mind, ensuring guests feel right at home during their stay. Whether you're strolling along the nearby beach or lounging by the pool, every moment at The Pridwin Hotel is sure to be memorable. Indulge in the beauty and tranquility of Shelter Island at this exceptional hotel.

2. House on Chase Creek

Indulge in the tranquil beauty of Shelter Island at the stunning House on Chase Creek. This charming 4-star guesthouse/bed and breakfast offers a peaceful retreat with its picturesque location on Locust Avenue. Check-in at 3:00 PM and unwind in one of the exquisitely designed rooms before exploring the island. With no chain affiliation, this boutique accommodation prides itself on personalized service and attention to detail. Enjoy a leisurely breakfast overlooking the creek, or take a short stroll to the nearby shops and restaurants. Immerse yourself in the serenity of Shelter Island at the House on Chase Creek, where relaxation meets luxury. Unwind, rejuvenate, and create lasting memories in this hidden gem of a hotel. Experience the charm and hospitality of Shelter Island at this exquisite retreat by the creek.

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

3. The Chequit

0.18 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

4. Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast

1.29 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Experience a charming getaway at Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast in Greenport, NY. Nestled on 424 4th Street, this intimate guesthouse offers a cozy retreat with breathtaking views of the water. Unwind in one of the well-appointed rooms, each designed with comfort in mind. With no chain affiliation, Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast provides a unique and personalized stay for every guest. Step outside and explore the picturesque surroundings or simply relax on the property's serene grounds. Indulge in a delicious breakfast each morning before beginning your day of exploration in this quaint coastal town. With a prime location in the heart of Greenport, you'll have easy access to local dining, shopping, and attractions. Immerse yourself in the charm of this historic seaside destination during your stay at Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast. Start making memories that will last a lifetime.

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

5. The Harbor Front Inn

1.47 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 7.9 /10 (21 reviews)

Discover the charm of The Harbor Front Inn, nestled in the heart of Greenport, New York. This 3-star hotel offers a cozy retreat with its 21 well-appointed rooms. Check-in at 4:00 PM and unwind in comfortable accommodations, complete with modern amenities. Located at 209 Front Street, this boutique hotel boasts a prime location near the waterfront and local attractions. Experience the warm hospitality and personalized service during your stay in this quaint coastal town. Feel relaxed and rejuvenated at this hidden gem in the United States.

Checkin : 4:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

6. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

1.48 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.3 /10 (9 reviews)

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

7. Greenporter Hotel

1.5 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 8.5 /10 (13 reviews)

Experience the charm of Greenport at the Greenporter Hotel, a 3-star accommodation located on Front Street in the heart of Greenport, New York. This boutique hotel offers a cozy atmosphere with modern amenities, ideal for travelers looking to relax and explore the picturesque surroundings. With 13 glowing reviews averaging 8.5, guests rave about the friendly staff, comfortable rooms, and convenient location near local attractions. Check-in is at 3:00 PM, and check-out is at 11:00 AM, ensuring a seamless stay for all guests. Although the number of rooms and floors is not specified, the Greenporter Hotel promises a unique and memorable experience. Visit this hidden gem and discover the beauty of Greenport at your doorstep.

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

8. American Beech Hotel

1.59 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.1 /10 (3 reviews)

Indulge in the charming ambiance of the American Beech Hotel, nestled in the heart of Greenport, NY. This 4-star gem offers a luxurious retreat with top-notch amenities and impeccable service. With a prime location on Main Street, guests are just steps away from the vibrant shops, restaurants, and wineries that define this picturesque town. The exquisite decor and cozy atmosphere of the hotel make for a truly memorable stay. Check-in at 3:00 PM and revel in the comfort of the elegantly designed rooms, where every detail is carefully curated for a relaxing experience. The American Beech Hotel boasts a total of 0 rooms spread across 0 floors, ensuring a peaceful and intimate setting for each guest. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway or a weekend escape, this boutique hotel is the perfect choice. Don't miss the opportunity to savor the delectable cuisine at the on-site restaurant, known for its farm-to-table dishes and exquisite wine selection. Discover the

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

9. The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport

1.63 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Experience luxurious waterfront lodging at The Stirling House Waterfront Inn in Greenport, NY. This 4-star guesthouse/bed and breakfast offers a tranquil escape with stunning views of the bay. Check-in at 4:00 PM and unwind in one of their beautifully designed rooms. With a prime location in the heart of Greenport, guests can easily explore the charming town and nearby attractions. The inn boasts elegantly appointed rooms, personalized service, and a delicious breakfast served each morning. Check-out time is at 11:00 AM, giving guests plenty of time to enjoy their stay. Escape to The Stirling House for a relaxing getaway on the water.

Checkin : 4:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

10. The Cliffside Resort Condominiums

2.29 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.4 /10 (2 reviews)

Escape to luxury at The Cliffside Resort Condominiums in beautiful Greenport, New York. This 3-star gem offers stunning views and top-notch amenities for a relaxing getaway. Check-in at 5:00 PM and enjoy the spacious accommodations in one of the entire apartments, each thoughtfully designed for your comfort. With only 2 reviews, the average rating is an impressive 9.4, a testament to the exceptional service and pristine accommodations. Check out by 10:00 AM and explore the charming surroundings of Greenport during your stay at this exquisite resort. With a convenient location and unparalleled hospitality, The Cliffside Resort Condominiums is the perfect choice for your next escape.

Checkin : 5:00 PM

Checkout : 10:00 AM

11. Hotel Moraine

2.33 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Checkin : 4:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

12. Sound View Greenport

2.43 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 8.7 /10 (66 reviews)

Uncover a hidden gem nestled in Southold, New York, at Sound View Greenport. This charming 3-star hotel boasts a picturesque location that promises a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. With 66 glowing reviews, this hotel offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly puts guests at ease. The check-in time is at 4:00 PM and check-out is at 11:00 AM for your convenience. Sound View Greenport features a unique design that perfectly complements the natural surroundings, creating a harmonious blend of comfort and style. Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway or a longer stay, this hotel promises a memorable experience that will leave a lasting impression. Immerse yourself in the beauty of the North Fork while enjoying top-notch amenities and personalized service at Sound View Greenport.

Checkin : 4:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

13. The Shoals Suites & Slips

2.71 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.7 /10 (3 reviews)

The Shoals Suites & Slips provides flawless service and all the necessary facilities for visitors. Stay connected with your associates, as complimentary Wi-Fi is available during your entire visit.When arriving by car, take advantage of the apartment's convenient on-site parking facilities. The apartment also features a fireplace, providing a cozy ambience during cool evenings. Start your day stress-free at The Shoals Suites & Slips as breakfast is made available for you on the premises.

Number of Rooms : 1

Checkin : 4PM

Checkout : 11AM

14. Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast

3.2 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Experience the charm and elegance of Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast, nestled in the picturesque town of East Marion, New York. This cozy guesthouse offers a tranquil retreat with its welcoming atmosphere and personalized service. Check-in at 3:00 PM and enjoy your stay in one of our beautifully appointed rooms before exploring the nearby attractions. Each room is tastefully decorated to ensure comfort and relaxation for our guests. Indulge in a delicious homemade breakfast served daily. Relax in the garden or take a stroll to the nearby beaches for a truly rejuvenating getaway. Check-out by 11:30 AM and leave feeling refreshed and renewed.

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:30 AM

15. Southold Beach Motel

3.21 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

16. A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast

3.68 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Indulge in a charming retreat at A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast in the picturesque city of Southold, NY. This cozy 3-star guesthouse boasts a serene atmosphere surrounded by nature, making it the perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. With a total of rooms and a welcoming ambiance, guests are treated to a personalized experience unlike any other. The check-in time is at 2:00 PM and check-out at 11:00 AM, allowing for a leisurely stay. Immerse yourself in the beauty of the United States' countryside while enjoying the comfort and hospitality of A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast.

Checkin : 2:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

17. White Blossom House Inn

4.54 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

18. Sag Harbor Inn

6.2 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 9.6 /10 (1 reviews)

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 11:00 AM

19. Baron's Cove

6.25 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Rated 10 /10 (1 reviews)

Welcome to the luxurious Baron's Cove hotel located in the charming city of Sag Harbor, NY. This 4-star hotel exudes elegance and sophistication, offering guests a truly unforgettable stay. With a prime location on 31 W. Water Street, Baron's Cove is the perfect choice for those seeking a relaxing getaway in the heart of the United States. Featuring a stunning waterfront setting, Baron's Cove boasts top-notch amenities and impeccable service. The hotel's 0 rooms are beautifully appointed and designed with the utmost comfort in mind. Check-in time is at 4:00 PM, and check-out time is at 12:00 PM for guests' convenience. Whether you're lounging by the pool or exploring the nearby attractions, Baron's Cove has something for everyone. Indulge in the hotel's fine dining restaurant, offering delicious culinary creations and sweeping views of the harbor. With a year opened in the past and an average rating of 10, Baron's Cove is a standout choice for

Checkin : 4:00 PM

Checkout : 12:00 PM

20. EHP Resort & Marina

9.98 Km from Shelter Island (NY)

Escape to the picturesque EHP Resort & Marina nestled in the heart of Springs, New York. This charming 3-star hotel offers a tranquil retreat with stunning views of Three Mile Harbor. Boasting modern amenities and warm hospitality, this hotel is perfect for both leisure and business travelers. Check-in at 3:00 PM and unwind in one of the beautifully appointed rooms overlooking the marina. The hotel features a marina for guests arriving by boat, as well as a restaurant serving delicious local cuisine. Explore the nearby beaches, wineries, and shops, or simply relax by the outdoor pool. Whether you're seeking adventure or relaxation, EHP Resort & Marina has something for everyone. Embrace the serene surroundings and create unforgettable memories at this hidden gem in the United States.

Checkin : 3:00 PM

Checkout : 12:00 PM

View more hotels

Top 20 Shelter Island (NY) Hotels (city in United States)

Shelter Island (NY) Hotels (city in United States)

1. The Pridwin Hotel

2. House on Chase Creek

3. The Chequit

4. Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast

5. The Harbor Front Inn

6. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

7. Greenporter Hotel

8. American Beech Hotel

9. The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport

10. The Cliffside Resort Condominiums

11. Hotel Moraine

12. Sound View Greenport

13. The Shoals Suites & Slips

14. Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast

15. Southold Beach Motel

16. A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast

17. White Blossom House Inn

18. Sag Harbor Inn

19. Baron's Cove

20. EHP Resort & Marina

Top Destination hotels near Shelter Island (NY)